Writing a strong proposal is only half the story. Before you start, you also need to know whether you are eligible, how the funding actually works and what happens once your proposal reaches the evaluators. These questions shape your whole application strategy, and they are often the hardest to find a clear answer to.
In Part 1 of this blog we looked at how to write a competitive MSCA or ERC proposal. In this second part, we focus on the rules behind the process: success rates and scores, how evaluators are selected and how they work, eligibility when changing research direction and how MSCA and ERC funding can be used.
What are the success rates for Horizon Europe, MSCA and ERC?
Success rates depend significantly on the year, scheme and call.
Horizon Europe overall
According to the European Commission’s monitoring data, the programme-wide success rate for fully evaluated Horizon Europe calls was 14% as of 30 June 2026. The annual rate decreased from 17% for calls closed in 2022 to 10% for calls closed in 2025.
ERC Starting Grants
For the 2025 ERC Starting Grant, 478 proposals were selected from 3,928 submissions, corresponding to a success rate of approximately 12.2%.
MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowships
For the 2026 MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowships call, 21,627 applications were submitted, while the Commission indicated that the available budget was expected to fund approximately 1,600 projects. Final success rates cannot be stated until evaluation and grant-selection results are available.
For the 2025 call, 17,066 proposals were received and the Commission expected to fund about 1,650 projects. Again, the expected number is not the same as a final success rate.
Why do some proposals apparently need scores of 90–95% to be funded, and how can evaluators distinguish between them?
A high funding threshold does not mean that 90–95% is a universal Horizon Europe requirement. Thresholds vary by call, available budget, number of applications and ranking.
The Commission reports that Horizon Europe has become more competitive: the programme-wide success rate fell from 17% for calls closed in 2022 to 10% for calls closed in 2025. The Commission attributes this to a substantial increase in proposal numbers, while budgets remain limited.
For ERC Starting Grants in 2025, only approximately 12.2% of submitted proposals were selected.
Evaluators distinguish proposals by applying the published evaluation criteria, not by assessing whether a proposal “feels like” a 90% proposal. In highly competitive calls, several proposals may be judged excellent, but only the highest-ranked can be funded within the available budget. For ERC, excellence is the sole criterion; Part I, the CV and track record are considered at Step 1, while the complete proposal, methodology, implementation, resources and feasibility are considered at Step 2.
Official sources: European Commission report on Horizon Europe competitiveness; ERC evaluation structure
How objective is the evaluation if evaluators’ workload and personal circumstances may affect how they read proposals?
The Commission selects experts on the basis of the expertise required and aims for balanced expert pools covering skills, experience, geographical diversity and gender.
For ERC, evaluation is organised through disciplinary panels and a two-step process. Part I and the PI information are examined at Step 1; the complete proposal and interview are considered at Step 2 for retained proposals.
No peer-review system can completely remove human judgment. Its advantage is that specialist researchers can assess scientific ambition, originality and disciplinary significance. Its potential limitations include differences in interpretation, disciplinary perspective and risk tolerance. The purpose of multiple reviewers, panel discussion, defined criteria and procedural safeguards is to reduce the influence of any single individual judgment.
Applicants should therefore make the proposal as easy as possible to evaluate against the official criteria, without relying on the reviewer to infer missing links.
Official sources: European Commission expert-selection principles; ERC evaluation structure
How can I become an evaluator for EU-funded projects?
Register in the European Commission expert database through the Funding & Tenders Portal.
You will need an EU Login account and must complete your expert profile, including:
- personal details;
- languages;
- education and training;
- areas of expertise;
- professional experience;
- publications and other relevant achievements.
A profile must be 100% complete to be eligible for selection. Registration does not guarantee an assignment; experts are selected according to the expertise required for a particular call or task.
Official sources: European Commission expert registration guidance; REA information on becoming an evaluator
I am one year into an MSCA position. Can I apply for an ERC Starting Grant with a substantially different research direction?
Yes, in principle. Being an MSCA fellow does not require an ERC proposal to continue the same research topic.
ERC calls are bottom-up and open to proposals in any field. For the 2027 Starting Grant, researchers with up to ten years’ experience since completion of the PhD may apply, subject to the detailed eligibility and extension rules. Applicants must demonstrate a promising scientific track record and submit an excellent research proposal.
A change of direction can be credible if the application explains:
- why the new question is important;
- how the applicant’s previous experience enables the transition;
- which additional expertise, team members, collaborators or facilities will address genuine gaps;
- why the applicant is capable of leading the new direction independently.
Official sources: ERC Starting Grant eligibility and conditions; ERC 2027 application rules
Can I apply with a project outside my main expertise if I plan to publish one or two papers before applying?
There is no rule requiring the proposal to remain within the applicant’s existing narrow specialism. ERC proposals may be submitted in any research field. However, the applicant must present a scientific track record showing promise and an excellent proposal.
Official source: ERC Starting Grant: applicant profile and funding conditions
Can MSCA funding be used for an already ongoing postdoctoral project?
An MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowship is not normally used simply to reimburse or retroactively fund an existing postdoctoral appointment or work already performed.
The application is submitted jointly by the researcher and a beneficiary organisation for a defined fellowship project. European Postdoctoral Fellowships normally last between 12 and 24 months; Global Fellowships include an outgoing phase of 12–24 months and a mandatory 12-month return phase.
The researcher may already be employed as a postdoctoral researcher when applying, but:
- the proposed MSCA fellowship must meet the call’s eligibility conditions;
- the mobility rule must be respected;
- the fellowship activities must take place during the eligible project period;
- work carried out before the action starts cannot be retrospectively funded through the fellowship.
The precise answer depends on the current employment, host country, intended MSCA host and mobility history.
Official sources: MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowships: types, objectives and conditions; MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowships 2026 call information
Does the MSCA research, training and networking contribution have to be spent monthly? Can a large fieldwork cost be covered in advance?
The MSCA contribution is based on unit contributions, not on monthly reimbursement of each individual invoice. The institutional contribution supports research, training and networking activities, while a separate institutional contribution supports management and indirect costs. Detailed financial implementation is explained in the official MSCA Financial Guide.
The monthly unit is used to calculate the EU contribution linked to eligible person-months. It does not necessarily mean that exactly the same amount must be spent in each calendar month on research activities.
The fellow should discuss the planned fieldwork and its timing with the supervisor and the host institution’s finance or grants office before making commitments.
Official source: European Commission MSCA Financial Guide, version 2.0
Does an ERC Starting Grant cover the cost of a Certificate on the Financial Statements?
Yes, where a Certificate on the Financial Statements, or CFS, is required under the Grant Agreement, the cost of obtaining the certificate may be charged to the project, provided that it meets the general eligibility conditions.
A CFS is not automatically required for every ERC grant. Whether it is required, and the applicable threshold, are specified in the signed Grant Agreement. The Funding & Tenders Portal reporting system indicates when a certificate must be submitted and includes a field for declaring the cost of the certificate.
The final check should therefore be made against the project’s Grant Agreement Data Sheet and Article 24.2, rather than relying on a general threshold.
Conclusion: two halves of a successful application
Across these two posts, we have looked at both sides of a strong application: shaping your idea into a clear, convincing proposal, and understanding the rules that decide how it is assessed and funded. One doesn’t work without the other. An excellent idea can still trip over eligibility or budget details, and a flawless application can’t make up for an idea that isn’t ambitious enough.
So start early, keep the official sources as your reference point and don’t hesitate to ask questions and support to your host institution and colleagues who have been through the process before.





