FREE PROPOSAL TEMPLATE

Get your free 50-page RIA/IA Proposal Template

November 19, 2026

From idea to application: your MSCA and ERC questions answered (Part 1)

Researcher planning a project on a whiteboard in a laboratory

For many early-career researchers, an MSCA Postdoctoral Fellowship or an ERC Starting Grant is the first real chance to lead their own research. It is a step towards independence, visibility and a research agenda that is truly theirs. It is also a highly competitive process, where a great idea is only the starting point. How you frame it, structure it and show that you are the right person to lead it is what makes the difference.

In this two-part blog, we aim to answer the most common questions on the topic. The first part focuses on the proposal itself: how much time to plan, how to shape your idea, how to balance vision and detail, how to present your track record and how to use AI tools responsibly.

How much time should a first-time applicant spend preparing a proposal?

There is no official minimum preparation period. The ERC’s official guidance says applicants should not leave preparation until the last moment and should allow time for:

  • a proper literature review;
  • development of an ambitious idea beyond the next paper;
  • establishment of collaborations;
  • proposal drafting;
  • checking the proposal against the evaluation criteria;
  • feedback from outstanding scientists and colleagues;
  • repeated revision and checking.

Our practical recommendation: a first-time applicant should ideally begin serious preparation several months before the deadline. The scientific concept and host arrangements should be stabilised early, followed by full drafting, external feedback and several revision cycles. This is a recommendation based on proposal-development practice, not an official eligibility rule.

If I have several ideas, should I develop more than one proposal?

During the early concept-development stage, it can be useful to compare several ideas. For the final application, however, an ERC proposal should normally be built around one coherent central research vision, not several disconnected problems.

For the ERC Work Programme 2027:

  • an applicant may have only one proposal under evaluation at a time, except for Proof of Concept calls;
  • an applicant may submit only one proposal under the ERC Work Programme 2027.

The ERC explicitly advises applicants to submit only when the research idea is sufficiently mature.

Official source: ERC 2027 eligibility windows and submission restrictions

Where can applicants find successful proposals?

The European Commission and ERC generally publish information about funded projects, but they do not maintain a public repository containing the complete confidential proposals of successful applicants.

Applicants may obtain complete successful proposals directly from individual grantees if those grantees voluntarily agree to share them. However, such documents should not be redistributed without the owner’s permission.

In an ERC Starting Grant, is more emphasis placed on the core idea or on implementation?

Both matter, but they are emphasised differently at the two evaluation stages.

At Step 1, evaluators assess Part I together with the CV and track record. The primary emphasis is on the ambition of the idea and its capacity to advance current knowledge. Feasibility is no longer assessed at this stage in the same detailed manner. Part I should therefore present a convincing overall research strategy rather than a compressed technical work plan.

At Step 2, evaluators assess the complete proposal, including detailed methodology, implementation, work plan, risk management, resources and feasibility.

Therefore:

  • a visionary idea without credible implementation is unlikely to succeed at Step 2;
  • flawless implementation of a conventional or insufficiently ambitious idea is unlikely to carry the proposal through Step 1.

The core idea must be genuinely ambitious, while the implementation must demonstrate that the applicant knows how to investigate it rigorously.

Official source: ERC explanation of Step 1 and Step 2 evaluation

How should applicants balance sufficient detail with a clear and focused narrative?

A useful rule is to provide the decision-relevant detail at the point where the evaluator needs it.

For ERC:

  • Part I should make the overall idea, current state of knowledge, scientific questions, objectives and research strategy convincing.
  • Part II should provide the detailed methodology, work plan, risks, mitigation measures, budget and resources.

A good drafting approach is to write a comprehensive version first and then reduce repetition, background information and secondary examples. This preserves substantive detail while making the central message easier to identify.

Official source: ERC proposal structure and evaluation stages

How can I mention several technologies without making the proposal difficult to understand?

Do not remove important technologies merely to avoid jargon. Instead, introduce each technology through its function in the project.

A useful formulation is:

“The project will combine [technology A], which enables us to…, with [technology B], which will be used to…, and [technology C], which will validate…. Together, these technologies will allow us to answer [central research question].”

For an ERC proposal, the high-level technological strategy belongs in Part I, while detailed methodology and implementation belong in Part II. The ERC explicitly states that Part I presents the overall research strategy, while Part II covers methodology, work plan, risks, mitigation, budget and resources in detail.

Official source: ERC proposal structure and evaluation changes

Can support letters from collaborators demonstrate how a task outside our technological skill set will be achieved?

A support letter may demonstrate that a collaborator or facility is willing to contribute, but it should not replace the explanation in the proposal itself.

What should be highlighted in the researcher’s CV and career track?

For ERC Starting Grants, highlight evidence that the applicant:

  • has produced promising scientific work;
  • is ready to conduct research independently;
  • has the intellectual capacity to lead the proposed direction;
  • has made identifiable contributions to the field;
  • can assemble and lead the required research environment.

The official ERC description refers to applicants with a scientific track record showing great promise and an excellent research proposal.

The CV and track record should help evaluators understand:

  • the applicant’s own contribution to major outputs;
  • progression toward independence;
  • relevant methodological or interdisciplinary competence;
  • leadership, supervision or coordination experience where applicable;
  • invited talks, awards, datasets, software, patents or other field-relevant outputs;
  • career circumstances that provide necessary context, where the application form allows this.

Avoid turning the CV into a list of personality claims such as “highly motivated” or “excellent communicator.” Demonstrate these qualities through evidence and achievements. Broad experience is useful when its relevance to the proposed project is made explicit.

Official source: ERC Starting Grant applicant profile

Can I use ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini to improve the language of an ERC proposal?

Yes, but the applicant retains full and sole responsibility for the proposal.

The ERC recognises that researchers may use AI or human assistance to brainstorm, search literature, revise, translate or summarise text. However, using external assistance does not remove the applicant’s responsibility concerning:

  • authorship;
  • acknowledgements;
  • plagiarism;
  • factual accuracy;
  • good scientific and professional conduct.

Practical safeguards include:

  • do not allow AI to invent references, preliminary results or methods;
  • verify every factual and bibliographic statement;
  • do not use AI-generated generic claims instead of project-specific reasoning;
  • check the AI tool’s privacy and data-use terms before entering unpublished or confidential material;
  • follow the host institution’s own policy on generative AI.

AI may improve grammar and readability, but it should not replace the applicant’s scientific judgment or original intellectual contribution.

Official source: ERC Scientific Council position on AI in proposal preparation


A strong idea deserves a strong proposal

When writing your ERC or MSCA proposal you should go beyond a mere description of your research and highlight why this idea matters, why now and why you are the right person to lead it. Start early, build everything around one clear vision, put the right level of detail where evaluators will look for it and let evidence speak for your track record. Support letters and AI tools can help along the way, but they cannot replace your own reasoning.

Stay tuned for Part 2, where we turn to the rules of the game: success rates, eligibility, MSCA funding and how evaluators actually score proposals.

Author

Gloria Bevilacqua

Author

Gabriella Lovász

Leave the first comment

Related Blog Posts

Reviewer examining a document with a magnifying glass

November 19, 2026

Rules, funding and evaluation: your MSCA and ERC questions answered (Part 2)

Writing a strong proposal is only half the story. Before you start, you also need to know whether you are…

Read more

October 20, 2026

Amendment Requests: The Most Misunderstood Tool in Horizon Europe Project Management

Few topics create as much unnecessary concern in Horizon Europe project management as amendment requests. Mention the possibility of launching…

Read more

October 20, 2026

Surviving Proposal Season: A Proposal Manager’s Survival Kit

There are certain signs that a proposal deadline is approaching. The inbox gets fuller. Calendars that looked manageable a few…

Read more

Sign up to our newsletter and get 5% off our courses!

Subscribe to our EU Research & Innovation Updates and get the latest information on our free and paid webinars, training courses, EU projects tips and tricks and EU news.

Newsletter